Podcasts

Amplix VP of Mobility Solutions Peter DiNatale on Why Company-Owned Phones Can Cost Less Than BYOD

Listen on:
Share this:

Episode Description:

In this Inside Amplix episode, Shawn sits down with Peter DiNatale, VP of Mobility Solutions at Amplix, to explain why the BYOD pendulum is swinging back toward company-owned devices. Security and compliance pressure in industries like healthcare and finance is a major driver, and the economics may surprise you. Peter breaks down how a sub-$30 all-in rate per line can beat a $75 to $100 monthly stipend, why owning the phone number protects customer relationships when employees leave, and how to roll out the transition with a 10-device proof of concept. They also dig into where savings hide in most mobility environments, from the gap between procurement and IT to renegotiating a contract mid-term, and how a free health check shows you what you have in five to ten business days.

What You’ll Learn:

  • Why enterprises that adopted BYOD to avoid managing devices are now bringing them back in house
  • How security and compliance requirements in healthcare and finance are driving the shift to company-owned phones
  • Why a sub-$30 all-in rate can cost far less than a $75 to $100 monthly BYOD stipend
  • Why owning the phone number is a business asset, especially for sales teams when employees leave
  • How to transition without disrupting IT or users, starting with a 10-device proof of concept
  • Where mobility savings hide, from the disconnect between procurement and IT to carriers you haven’t shopped in years
  • How to renegotiate a carrier contract you just signed, and how to catch international roaming charges mid-cycle
  • What a free mobility health check reveals in five to ten business days, including device age, zero-use lines, and where your money goes

Transcript:

Shawn Cordner (00:11.744)

Hey everyone and welcome to the Amplitude of Tech Podcast. I’m Shawn Cordiner, Chief Marketing Officer of Amplix. This is the Inside Amplix edition of the podcast. What does that mean? We’re going to bring you thought leadership from Amplix employees, actionable intel and insights that we’ve learned by doing thousands and thousands of technology transformation projects. Hope you enjoy the episode.

 

Shawn Cordner (00:38.318)

All right, Peter DiNatale. Welcome to the Inside Amplix edition of the Amplitude of Tech Podcast. So let’s start off with who you are, what you do here at Amplix.

 

Peter DiNatale (00:44.13)

Thank you.

 

Peter DiNatale (00:49.992)

I’m Peter, as you said, and I basically had up all things mobility as we released Amplix to our customer.

 

Shawn Cordner (00:57.122)

So the people listening might not know and I don’t want to make this commercial about Amplix, but we have a lot of we have a whole mobility practice and we have a lot of depth of expertise and resources. So what kind of you know, when we say mobility practice, what do we mean? Like what are the services that we offer?

 

Peter DiNatale (01:14.958)

Well that’s a that’s a big question, right? So we we cover the full life cycle managed services for mobility in the enterprise space from A to from A to Z. So is there a specific topic you wanna zone in on?

 

Shawn Cordner (01:28.908)

Yeah, I wanted to start off with you know, I had heard recently that there was a a trend towards going away from the BYOD environment, bringing your own device environment and moving towards corporate owned environments. So I thought maybe we could start there. I understand that you’ve been tracking this trend for over the past year or so, but maybe kind of talk to me about, you know, prior state, what was the driver to going to BYOD as opposed to corporate?

 

owned and then why is the trend reversing and going the other way?

 

Peter DiNatale (02:03.158)

Yeah, the pendulum’s going the other way. the reason why everybody wanted to go PYOD is ’cause they just didn’t want to manage devices. IT just didn’t want to have to deal with end users. They don’t want to deal with break fix and all the questions that go along with managing a device. They just had enough of it that, like, you know what, we’ll just give you a monthly stipend. You just deal with Apple Store and and warranty and capabilities on your own, and we’re done. We’re out of the market. But

 

that has changed because of security as a primary driver, especially in healthcare and finance, right? The compliance issues and HIPAA and GCR, where companies are now being have to bring that the are looking at bringing that device in-house. And when you try as a company to layer in your security protocols and applications on a personal device, it gets complicated and users don’t want to have their devices managed.

 

So it’s gotten to the point where companies are like, you know what? Keep your device. We’re going to issue all brand new devices with the with the applications and security protocol that we want. The number we’re going to issue brand new numbers. And those numbers are the asset of the business. So if anyone was to leave the company, they own that number and just take complete control of it. And then it ties into the buy rate, right? Based on the rates that are out there, they’re getting a much better buy rate than doing the stipend that they do today. So it accomplishes

 

a couple of different goals by bringing it in in house.

 

Shawn Cordner (03:31.32)

So one of the I I feel like one of the benefits to BYOD for the users was they didn’t have to carry around a second phone and it was maybe a matter of preference, right? They they didn’t want to have to bifurcate their mobile experience. But now because of the security protocols and because how tightly these these need to be locked down, you know, do you see that there’s friction with the users that they don’t want this experience, or is it actually that

 

Maybe they’re a little bit relieved because at this point they’re starting to feel like, Well, what does my company have access to on my phone and maybe there’s privacy concerns there?

 

Peter DiNatale (04:10.326)

Yeah, it’s a bit of both, right? Do I want to carry two devices? Not really. there are some best practices around my ability with iPhones, with the with the E sims and two E sims, right? So I could actually have my personal I could have my business line and then actually put my personal line as long as my device is unlocked on the one device and still carry one device. So it is possible, but most people aren’t doing it. But it’s just

 

It’s just this is the mandate from the company that says, Here’s our corporate device, you have to use it for anything corporate related and whatever you do personal on your personal device, it is what it is.

 

Shawn Cordner (04:47.414)

What are the economics of this? Because it it seems like to me that, you know, a corporate liable environment is going to be a bigger capital expense, maybe a bigger operating expense. It sounded like you said that you could get more favorable rates from that direction and that it the amount per line that you would be paying may actually end up being less than what the stipend would be that you’re providing in a BYOD environment. Is that right?

 

Peter DiNatale (05:13.102)

That is a hundred percent correct. So the p different companies do different things. A hundred dollar stipend a month per user, fifty dollars, seventy five, whatever it is. Right now, all in with the carriers, with like a a a more current phone, iPhone sixteen, seventeen, with the unlimited data, voice and texting, we’re seeing rates sub three thirty dollars. So if you’re doing a hundred dollars a month, now you’re getting sub thirty times a thousand you seventy dollars a device, savings times a thousand devices.

 

No, it’s a significant number that

 

Shawn Cordner (05:44.624)

Savings offset by the cost of buying the devices themselves?

 

Peter DiNatale (05:49.55)

The savings are offset by the device. You’re buying the device, it’s all inclusive with the comp with the rate at that sub thirty dollar rate. So

 

Shawn Cordner (06:00.438)

Interesting. So why is the why is it easier to just lock this down from a security perspective? Like I you know, why can’t you just install MDM or the you know the SAS applications that the company runs off of? What are the actual exposures?

 

Peter DiNatale (06:19.168)

Yeah, it’s just it just it comes down to the end user and their willingness or lack thereof to allow corporate applications on the devices, sandboxing those the those applications compared to personal. When the rubber hits the road, it just it just too much back and forth, minutiae associated with the conversations, and then the company just says, you know, we’re done. We’re just we gotta make this

 

Less is more. We need to make this simple. We just need to own the asset. We need to basically be able to deploy the applications on that asset with the security protocol for compliance reasons and just in general, limit you know, limit the vulnerabilities we have. trying to people, you know, if a cell phone is an act is an act access point, access point on into their network. So they just just just making that decision. A lot of companies that just this is it, just you know, go with the corporate device.

 

Shawn Cordner (07:13.688)

So for a company that’s going that direction or is listening to this and thinking maybe this is a solution to a challenge that they’re facing in their environment, how big of a transition is this to go from BYOD to corporate liable?

 

Peter DiNatale (07:29.324)

Yeah, so it’s a great question. And I’ll go back to the original question of why did they go PYOD? ‘Cause they didn’t want to manage devices. So now the IT departments have to bring the devices in house, they have to manage them. So that’s where our managed services come into play, right? So if we’re doing a sub thirty dollar rate for the hardware and the rate plan, and then they was doing a stipend of a hundred or seventy five dollars, well later on our platinum or you know, gold package that we have where

 

even if you add ten dollars a month to that thirty dollars at forty, we’ll do handle all of it, right? As much as the client wants or as much as the client doesn’t want. They could literally just point their end user to an eight hundred number and then we’ll basically take it from there. So even with that additional expense, it’s way less expensive than the BYOD stipend model. And we’re solving for them not having to manage devices, which is a huge concern for companies

 

When they try to bring it in house.

 

Shawn Cordner (08:28.568)

But as even before that though, even before we get into the management of it, just actually making that transition. it sounds like it might be a nightmare if you’ve got a a few thousand lines to have to deploy all these things into the field at one time. Like how do you how do you recommend doing this so that it’s not disruptive to the IT department or to the users?

 

Peter DiNatale (08:50.646)

Yeah, so I mean it is a concern, right? You have to do preparation. You need to basically do a POC on ten devices, make sure you load the apps that you need and it meets the business needs, roll them out into the field and then everything goes smooth, identify any issues, which is what we do again in our managed services. and and then just rinse and repeat after that, right? You just you just wanna be prepared going into that.

 

And it’s not just it’s not just going from BYOD to corporate owned devices. This that also plays into just doing a technology refresh. Sure. Right? The companies but we do our health checks, we and we drive savings for the client. One of the things that comes out in that health check is what kind of devices do they have today? Are the devices compliant? How old are they? Do they even get iOS updates anymore because their iPhone Xs are are older?

 

So doing a refresh every two or three years should be a common pra it is a common practice for a lot of customers, but that workload or that workflow that goes into switching to new devices, it’s the same workflow as if even if you were just going from BYOD to corporate owned devices. But corporate owned devices is easier because now you’re not doing backup restores of the data. It’s all it’s just a new device. You’re not worried about their old data doing that. So that that’s one piece that can be arduous. So

 

But we we have we have a whole program of prep’s practice around how to, you know, guarantee a a really smooth transition of technology refresh or going from BYOD to corporate owned devices.

 

Shawn Cordner (10:27.278)

Sure. Are there other strategic advantages or business advantages to going to this direction? And the one that I was thinking was specifically owning the phone number. So, you know, it let’s take salespeople, for example, salespeople that are bringing their own device to a job. they’re gonna be communicating with clients of prospects via that device. That’s gonna be their phone number. So that means if and when they leave the company, those channels of communications, those relationships are still tied to

 

the phone number that the sales rep is taking with them. So I you know, I know that you’re not gonna mitigate that completely by going to a corporate liable, but it does seem that there would be a benefit to continuity f of account support or sales support once, you know, you own that phone number.

 

Peter DiNatale (11:14.946)

Yeah, I mean I have my number for twenty plus years, right? All of my relationships that I’ve created over my career and my friends are all associated with that number. So if I had a choice as an owner of a business, I would want to own that asset to mitigate that as best as possible. Now, do you reserve the right to give them the number? Absolutely. But as a company, but you also reserve the right to keep it.

 

Shawn Cordner (11:42.264)

Yeah. I guess this is a good transition because some people, myself included, might be surprised to hear that moving to a corporation is a way to generate cost savings, not just mitigate the security risks that they’re facing. are there any other surprise places that people could look in the mobility environment to find savings? Like where do you where do you tend to see the biggest mistakes that end up driving up costs?

 

Peter DiNatale (12:09.23)

Well, I it’s a there’s a huge disconnect between procurement and IT. So procurement negotiates the deal, IT implements the deal, but there’s no checks and balances between the two. No one’s checking to see if you got the right deal. And then on a as an extension of that, when was the last time company actually shopped their their their their business their environment? What what is that what is their environment worth in the current marketplace?

 

An example that I could use is I’ll ask you, when was the last time you shopped your home your home mortgage your your home your home policy for your house?

 

Shawn Cordner (12:48.502)

Probably when I bought it.

 

Peter DiNatale (12:49.74)

Yeah. So I just recently did it. I haven’t done it in twenty years. What did I do? I saved thirty percent. ‘Cause I I A I I didn’t think I could negotiate a better deal. I just thought all th insurances are the same. Or I just didn’t have the time and to put into it. And I’m just like, okay, let me just take a f a step here and and go to a broker that represents all the different carriers. They shopped the book of business and lo and behold came back with savings. So this that’s very similar to technology and and specific to mobility, right?

 

You’re with the one carrier, you wanna see if you have the best rate with that carrier, and then you wanna see if the other carriers can give you a better rate. And and even if they can give you a better rate, you now you have competitive intelligence. You just have general knowledge as to whether or not you have the best rate. And you’re not forced to go from one carrier to the other. You just now you’re educated and you can make good business decisions based on your book of business to help drive savings.

 

Shawn Cordner (13:44.002)

Yeah, that makes sense. Are there any other places that you might look? for example, like what about real time I I’ve heard of platforms that allow for or enable real time adjustment of your calling plans based off of actual usage or calling patterns, international, for example. is that a place that people, you know, tend to make a mistake is not optimizing their rates?

 

Peter DiNatale (14:09.132)

Yeah, yes and no, right? no when I say no is because most of the plans that we’re provisioning today are unlimited. Set it and forget it. So there’s no more managing to a set of data pools when it comes to smartphones. Not necessarily the case when it comes to hotspots and and you know routers and things of that nature. So it’s still a a need for mana managing the data pool for data devices. and then actually if you you know

 

Leveraging a platform that can give you an alert that you have a user traveling internationally that doesn’t have an international plan and then the ability to f with that platform to add the international plan mid mid cycle of the billing and prorate it back to the beginning of the billing cycle is huge, right? So you don’t find out after the fact that you got a five thousand dollar bill, you’ve triaged it in the middle of it and then make you know, took appropriate action to make sure you don’t get that huge hit. So

 

Yeah, the the platform in general will help deliver on other potential savings like that as well.

 

Shawn Cordner (15:11.82)

So I’ve heard a pretty wide range of percentage of savings that usually just exists in anybody’s mobility environment. seems like the industry we always default to twenty, thirty percent, but you know, I think our data shows it it could be as low as fourteen, fifteen percent, it could be as high as approaching sixty percent savings, just latent savings that’s sitting there that really doesn’t take much effort to go about

 

it it doesn’t take effort, it takes expertise and just a little bit of attention, right? and then I I think it is also savings that can hit really quickly. You can hit the balance sheet really quickly, right? Because these are savings that you know, once you make that adjustment, it it hit hits the next billing cycle. So thoughts on any of that? Is that true?

 

Peter DiNatale (15:59.094)

No, that’s true. I mean it’s a you never know what you’re gonna find bepending on the customer. the the the the range of savings is could be significant, like you said. so it’s just a matter of seeing what they have and so as far as implementing the savings, right? So hey, Mr. Customer, here’s what you have today, implement our recommendations, this is your savings, we can implement that within thirty day bill cycle, right? So realize that on that P and L immediately, make an immediate

 

impact. If we’re gonna get into contract negotiations with the carriers to help drive additional savings on top of that, that’s where that could take more time. But even then that’s not you know, that’s a sixty, ninety day turnaround time. So depending on where you are in your s your release cycle, it could still hit the P and O significantly within that year.

 

Shawn Cordner (16:46.646)

Now, what about people that are listening to this that are interested in the savings, but they just recently renewed a contract or you know migrated over somebody that’s kind of locked into an existing contract. Are they out of luck until that contract’s up or is there something that can be done to to optimize, you know, in flight of a contract?

 

Peter DiNatale (17:06.273)

Yeah, you could do an addendum to the existing contract. There’s nothing stopping you from renegotiating even an existing co recent contract to a better contract. ’cause you’re still staying with them, right? You’re not leaving them. You’re just saying, Hey, I’m educated. I think I can do better. These are the reasons why. And and then try to negotiate that those changes and then do an addendum to drive those savings.

 

Shawn Cordner (17:30.542)

This is one of those things I feel like on the telecom side of the industry, it really takes a lot of institutional and tribal knowledge about how these things work and how these carriers work in order to really navigate cost optimization and contract term optimization. that’s obviously a a plug for the expertise that we have here. You you want to partner with someone that does this day in, day out as opposed to, you know, once every three years if they’re lucky.

 

so if there’s someone listening to this that has some questions or wants to take a closer look at their mobility environment, how would you recommend they take the first steps and you know, I would assume it’s reach out to you or their sales rep. So how do they how do they reach you?

 

Peter DiNatale (18:14.722)

Yeah, reach out to the mobility team or their account executives, which will reach out to the mobility team and then we’ll start the process to do our free health check, right? And and basically takes five to ten business days from the time that we receive the raw data from their portals to come back and give them the results of the that that study. And then it speaks for itself. It it tells a story, it goes way beyond just savings and optimization, tells you exactly how many devices you have, what type of devices do you have.

 

Are the older devices? How many zero use devices do you have? And then then you can because you have everything in front of you, not on a this 500 page bill, you know, I I want to say a glorified Excel spreadsheet, but at least you have the data that you can make really good business decisions on to either ac act on some of it or all of it, whatever makes the best the best sense for the business. But it all starts with just reaching out to the rep and saying, Hey, can you help us out?

 

Shawn Cordner (19:10.562)

Got it. I appreciate it. Peter Dino Talley, thanks for your time and expertise.

 

Peter DiNatale (19:13.74)

My pleasure. A lot of great questions. I appreciate it. Thanks.

 

Show more...

Related Episodes